The Top 10 Best Standup Specials of the 2010s

All of these released on Netflix. I don't know if that says more about me or the current state of standup. Probably me.

The Top 10 Best Standup Specials of the 2010s

10. Daniel Sloss: Jigsaw

Daniel Sloss performing Jigsaw
"Doubt isn’t a flower, doubt’s a weed. I don’t need to water it."

Daniel Sloss and I do not share a sense of humor. This show is even less funny to me than Nanette, an act that of course appears later on this list. But the message of Jigsaw grabs you and does not let go. It is astonishingly cynical about love, but not in a hacky way. It's not a guy talking about how much his wife annoys him, clearly in denial about how deeply unhappy he is, it's a guy talking about how happy he is being alone who appears very in touch with his own emotions. As a badge of honor, Sloss keeps a tally in his Twitter bio of the breakups this show has caused, and at the time of this writing it is over 45,000. If you watch Jigsaw, you will see why, and you won't be able to forget it.

9. Patton Oswalt: Annihilation

Patton Oswalt performing Annihilation
"It's chaos. Be kind."

Patton Oswalt has been funny for, like, forever, and he's even funny in this heartbreaking account of the first- and second-worst days of his life, and the "numb slog" after that. But more importantly than funny, he's honest, about the depths of pain that he's hit and the parts of losing a loved one that no one talks about because they're almost insultingly messy.

8. Hasan Minhaj: Homecoming King

Hasan Minhaj performing Homecoming King
"This is new brown America. The dream is for you to take."

Homecoming King debuted as a one-man show, and, in a way, it still is. I want to avoid being pedantic about what's a standup show and what isn't, but you can really feel Homecoming King's roots as a one-man show in the engaging, poetic way Minhaj pulls you into his story. The second-generation immigrant story spans almost Minhaj's entire life, and it will be rich and rewarding to those who know exactly what he's talking about and those who are only given a brief glimpse into being an outsider.

7. Taylor Tomlinson: The Comedy Lineup

Taylor Tomlinson performing her set for The Comedy Lineup
"I was an 'old soul', which is what adults call you when they don't want to say 'loser' in front of your parents."

Netflix's series of 15-minute comedy specials had a lot of great entries, but the standout was Taylor Tomlinson. Yes, this set is only a quarter-hour long, but that makes it even more notable to me that it's become such a favorite of mine. Maybe it's just that Tomlinson's snarky ambivalence towards being in your twenties hits alarmingly close to home for me, but I give her credit because this short performance displays remarkable writing, inflection, and physicality. Considering this is a debut special, the 2020s look very bright for Taylor Tomlinson.

6. Nate Bargatze: The Standups

Nate Bargatze performing his set for The Standups
"You know that saying, 'I haven't had that in forever'? I haven't said that in forever."

Before there was The Comedy Lineup, Netflix kicked off their comedy-sampling experiment with a series of thirty-minute sets, and Nate Bargatze performed his best material ever in the first episode. While he's done plenty of solid work before this, his self-deprecating humor and his story about the Cape Fear Serpentarium are hilariously deadpan enough to be a career standout.

5. Bo Burnham: Make Happy

Bo Burnham performing Make Happy
"I'm not honest for a second up here!"

Bo Burnham's specials feel like a tasty dessert. The spectacle of it all is so fun to watch while we walk directly into Burnham's traps and wait for him to outsmart us in the funniest way possible. We were lucky to get another serving of this in 2016 with Make Happy, which was still mostly about comedy and performing but also about the performer, creating some really memorable moments and being more emotionally affecting than his standup has been before.

4. Aziz Ansari: Buried Alive

Aziz Ansari performing Buried Alive
"Does the word 'unlimited' come to mind?"

You can probably tell that I tend to like comedy with some kind of gimmick. This is the last show on this list that I would call "gimmick-free". Aside from some very sharp and very fortunate crowd work, it's pretty much a vanilla standup set, and since it came out it's been my go-to recommendation for people who don't share my nerdy tastes. Ansari asks the questions he's been wondering about since turning 30 in an act that's amazingly polished and professionally delivered.

3. Hannah Gadsby: Nanette

Hannah Gadsby performing Nanette
"Bit of lesbian content there. I'll be sprinkling it throughout the show."

Many of the reasons Nanette is unique are talked about in the show itself. And not in a pretentious way, it's just the fact that this show is unique for things that shouldn't be unique in mainstream comedy. But, as Gadsby lays out in soul-crushing truth, the stories of people like her, if they're told completely honestly, are often not compatible with standup comedy as a form. Nanette will get you used to the typical standup format of tension and release, and then slowly draw back the release, until you see, clearly, there is no release.

2. Bo Burnham: what.

"Never waste a moment! Every moment can become a comedic moment!"

Looking back on Burnham's three specials, my main criticism is that they all say pretty much the exact same thing. But what. was the one that said it the best, marking an absolutely monumental leap from his previous work. It begins with an almost seven-minute song that can only be described as an exhilarating showcase of comedic tricks, and as far as I know there's no one else you would see on Netflix who's even tried to replicate it. Burnham spends the hour deconstructing every atom that makes up a comedy show, and he has something to say about all of them. The lights, backing tracks, and audience expectations are all part of it, coming together to make a tirelessly rehearsed, brilliantly performed spectacle, that, as the cherry on top, he also released for free on YouTube.

Speaking of how far Bo Burnham has come, my honorable mention is his special Words Words Words, which was a clear indication of the star's potential. It's crazy to think of how far he evolved in the three years after this show, but what's also astounding is how much talent he had at just twenty years old. Words Words Words now feels dated in both its sense of humor and even its references, but it's insane that the youngest person to ever get an hour-long Comedy Central special could put out something so advanced.

1. James Acaster: Repertoire

James Acaster performing Repertoire
"It's about me, start to finish, the whole show."

If you haven't seen Repertoire, you probably don't know that it's actually four standup specials released all at once on Netflix. But if you watch it, you'll understand why I'm counting it all as one thing. And if you get a critically worshiped comedian like Acaster, take three of his highly acclaimed shows from throughout his career, and add in another one as an assortment of his older work that also somehow makes the other three even better, how could that not be #1 to a comedy fan like me?

And yet, Acaster went so far beyond the extra mile with Repertoire. Talking about how is kind of spoiling it, but since this is my #1 and I think Acaster should be more well-known in America than he is, I really want to talk about it anyway. That's all that's left in this article, so if you haven't seen the set yet, I highly encourage you not to read the rest of this and go watch it, preferably all at once. Don't worry about the nerdy reasons why it's amazing or look for things you're not supposed to see yet, just enjoy it. Acaster's clever jokes delivered through observational comedy and whimsical premises would put it in my top 10 by themselves. Okay, spoilers follow.

Some reasons why Repertoire is the greatest standup special of the 2010s:

  1. The show titles, which all also begin with "Re", actually relate to the shows and are a signifier of what they contain. Every show has a story that runs throughout it, but that story also shares a theme with many of the seemingly unrelated jokes in the margins. Recognise is about pretending to be someone you're not, Represent is about doubt, Reset is about wanting a fresh start, and Recap is about repetition. This isn't something I'm used to seeing in standup and not something I really noticed on my first watch, so I think it's really cool.
  2. The nonlinear timeline is really rewarding. I discovered Repertoire in October of this year. Can you guess how many times I've watched it since then? I'll give you a hint, it's more than three. Aside from being an awesome reveal and a great way to close the series, its complexity makes it so rewatchable, and tracking all the genius happening here is a tall order even on multiple viewings. Recap even connects Reset to its theme even further by revealing that it had taken the viewer over 10 years into the past as far as the continuity of the series is concerned, and don't forget that since Recap is retroactively revealing that about the previous episode, that also makes it itself more connected to its own theme of repetition. Jesus.
  3. Everything flows together. As soon as each show begins and sometimes including the beginning itself, literally everything is set up by what comes before it. There are zero hard pivots or random topic changes. This isn't totally unique to Repertoire, but it just makes it that much better. The show is plenty surprising, but nothing comes out of nowhere.
  4. Acaster is a consummate professional. While this may be his first broadcasted special, no one would ever mistake him for someone without immense experience. His delivery is top-notch.

I unfortunately did not get to see Acaster's latest show, Cold Lasagne Hate Myself 1999, when he toured it in the States, but according to critics it is even better than these. I mean this in the best way possible, praying that it one day gets recorded and released: I'll believe it when I see it.